Posted by Nydia Streets of Streets Law in Florida Paternity
Once paternity of a child is established, there are limited circumstances under which paternity can be disestablished. Florida generally recognizes out-of-state orders establishing paternity. Disestablishment of paternity was an issue in the case Gragg-Rivera v. Gragg, 5D2023-1566 (Fla. 5th DCA July 12, 2024).
In this divorce case, the trial court disestablished the former husband’s paternity of the parties’ oldest child. The former wife appealed this issue, but because she did not provide a transcript of the proceedings, review was limited to what was contained in the final judgment. The appellate court held “To begin, a parent/child relationship established by a decree from another state is recognized in Florida ‘unless such status or the rights flowing therefrom are not contemplated by or are repugnant to the laws or policy of the state of Florida upon the subject.’ Mott v. First Nat’l Bank, 124 So. 36, 37 (Fla. 1929). In this proceeding, Former Wife attached a January 2007 order from the State of Virginia that decreed Former Husband as the legal father of the oldest child. Former Wife also attached the original and amended birth certificates and social security cards of the oldest child that reflected the addition of Former Husband’s surname. In the absence of any record evidence to the contrary, the trial court erred in sua sponte disestablishing the paternity of the oldest child that was duly established in Virginia. As such, the trial court’s ruling is reversed; the trial court shall reinstate Former Husband as the legal parent of the oldest child, as reflected in the Virginia decree. In addition, the amended final judgment shall be modified on remand to provide for past child support and to vacate any finding or claim that Former Husband’s payment of child support was somehow fraud.”
Schedule your meeting with a Miami family law attorney to understand how the law may apply to the facts of your case.